The Autonomy of the Ability Condition for the Analytic Project in Epistemology

Authors

  • Abel Wajnerman Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas; Universidad de Buenos Aires

Keywords:

analysis of knowledge, virtue epistemology, ability condition, epistemic twin earth, detection mechanisms

Abstract

Pritchard intends to revitalize the analytic project in the theory of knowledge: offering an informative and non-circular characterization of knowledge. He believes that this can be done if we notice that the two main intuitions about knowledge imply independent conditions. I argue that we can characterize knowledge using only the ability condition, without appealing to an independent condition. The main case against the sufficiency of the ability condition is the epistemic twin earth case. I claim that it does not work if we acknowledge that the relevant ability is not merely a perceptual faculty but a more complex detection mechanism.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Abel Wajnerman, Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas; Universidad de Buenos Aires

Abel Wajnerman es doctor en filosofía por la Universidad de Buenos Aires. Sus investigaciones de posgrado han sido “Distinción y relación entre conceptos y perceptos en las diferentes formas de conocimiento perceptual” y “La teoría computacional de la mente y la realización de los procesos cognitivos”. Es miembro del grupo Cognición, Lenguaje y Percepción, a cargo de Liza Skidelsky, e investigador asociado del Programa de Neuroética del Centro de Investigaciones Filosóficas, dirigido por Arleen Salles.

Published

2017-05-30

How to Cite

Wajnerman, A. (2017). The Autonomy of the Ability Condition for the Analytic Project in Epistemology. Latin American Journal of Philosophy, 43(1), 9–27. Retrieved from https://rlfcif.org.ar/index.php/RLF/article/view/12

Issue

Section

Articles